Pie Maven title
Contact Contact Contact  Contact  Contact  Contact 

 

Holiday Pie

Most people limit their pie preparation and/or intake to the holiday feasts of Thanksgiving, Christmas, and Easter.  (And that is a shame, because pie should be enjoyed on every occasion.  And for no occasion at all.)  Cake hogs the spotlight at birthdays, weddings, and every other special occasion, so these holidays are pie's chance to shine.  Even if you bake pies throughout the year, pull out all the stops for the holidays.  The pie aficionados will appreciate it, and the ignorants whose eyes (and palettes) have not yet been opened to the greatness of pie will be converted.  So go for it.  Make a pie that will wow them and throw them to the backs of their seats.

(And when the holiday is over, make the most of the leftovers.)

Thanksgiving Christmas  
Outdoor Holidays    

Holidays should be a time for gathering with loved ones who won't judge or criticize a less-than-perfect dish. And some of the best memories are made from the recipe gone wrong. But if you know that certain relative is going to nitpick, or you just want to make this gathering special, a phenomenal pie goes a long way.

(It can be very hard to prepare food for someone on a restricted diet.  You may need some diabetic, vegan, or gluten-free recipes.)

And if you need to transport or ship a pie, here's how.

 

Thanksgiving Pie

pumpkin pie with streusel toppingPumpkin pie is usually center stage at Thanksgiving.  Pecan, sweet potato, and apple also frequently play a role.

But why not change it up?

Autumn is the time of year for all gourds, not just pumpkin. Try switching out the pumpkin in the recipe for a butternut squash, or experiment with any of the exotic gourds typically found at the grocery store this time of year.

Instead of traditional pecan pie, try a bourbon pecan. Or go for pure decadence with a frozen caramel drizzle.

Apple pie is quintessential American.  But there's no reason it needs to be the same boring pie year after year.  Try apple raisin sour cream.  Or even a simple apple tart.  Or get those creative culinary juices flowing and substitute the apples in the recipe for a different fruit altogether, like pears.

Of course, the traditional pies are Thanksgiving mainstays for a reason. They're fantastic. Even if you decide to stick with the traditional route, you can still wow 'em. The easiest way to make a fantastic pie is to simply avoid the pitfalls that make a pie less fantastic.
apple pie with leaves
Everyone knows the hardest part of baking a pie is making the perfect flaky crust. If you're not experienced at that, skip the top crust altogether. Replace it with a crumb topping. Or use cookie cutters to turn your top crust into festive autumn shapes - no need to worry about tricky lattices or crimping and sealing edges.

With all the time spent slaving over the rest of the meal, you may want to rest a bit and whip together an easy cream pie. And best of all, they're easy to jazz up so they appear much more impressive than they actually are. you'd be surprised at how people will gush over a pie that took just a few minutes to throw together, just because of a little fancy garnish on top.

If your Thanksgiving celebration has a certain theme or atmosphere, try to select your pie recipe accordingly. Here are a few suggestions.

If your Thanksgiving is:

Try this recipe:

Home-style

Apple Pie 
Buttermilk Pie
Old-Fashioned Fudge Pie  
Old-Fashioned Sweet Potato Pie

Pecan Pie
Pumpkin Pie with Streusel
Sweet Potato Pie

Sophisticated

Amaretto Cheesecake
Bourbon Pecan Pie
Cranberry Cheesecake
Pistachio Pie
Sweet Potato and Sage Tart

Awkward

Frozen Caramel Drizzle Pie
Jack Daniel’s Pie
Raisin Pie
Whiskey Apple Pie

Lively

Chocolate Meringue Pie
Filled Cheesecake
Fluffernutter Pie
Sweet Potato Quiche

Depressing

Black Forest Cheesecake
Brownie Pie
Chocolate Chip Cheesecake
Rice Pudding Tart

Romantic

Cherry Pie  
Dark Chocolate Meringue Pie

Raspberry Custard Tart

Hectic

Apple Cobbler
Banana Cream Pie
Cherry Cobbler
Chocolate Cream Pie
No Bake Cheesecake

Christmas Pie

Most people are so focused on the gifts that the meal is barely an afterthought. And Christmas is so soon after the Thanksgiving feast (not to mention all the holiday parties and bingeing going on) that it's hard for anything to break through the holiday stupor. The challenge is to present a pie that will hold their attention for at least a few minutes.  Luckily after the usual fare of cakes and cookies, a pie really is something new and different. 

Forego the insidious fruitcake brick and send a delightful pie instead!

But what kind of pie is appropriate for the winter holidays? Pumpkin and apple were already played out in the fall. It's the wrong season for berries. Banana and peach are sadly out of season, as well.

Think white. Chocolate. Warmth.  Maybe a little peppermint.

Spruce it up with the typical holiday decor. Holiday cookie cutters are great for making fun shapes in the crust. Candy canes, holly sprigs, jingle bells. The fancier the garnish, the more the audience will oooh and aaah over it.

Some recommended Christmas pie recipes:   
Amaretto Cheesecake
Angel Cheesecake Pie

Bailey's Irish Cream Mousse Pie
Candy Cane Cheesecake
Grasshopper Pie
Macadamia Nut Pie
Marble Cheesecake
Mincemeat Pie  (Mincemeat is typically associated with Christmas.)
Peppermint Stick Pie
Red Velvet Cheesecake
White Chocolate Raspberry Pie

4th of July, Memorial Day, and other outdoorsy holidays

There are many "eat outside" holidays.  So you'll need a pie that will travel well and hold up to the summer heat.  Custards are out.  And you probably don't want to make anything that requires lengthy oven time.  Try:

Apricot Tart
Peach Raspberry Cobbler
Fluffernutter Pie
Frozen Lemonade Pie
Strawberry Jell-O Pie

Or if you need a main course instead of dessert, a BBQ Pie is great because there's no dairy to rot in the sun.

Go Pie!